FJR Owners Forum banner

Fork Seal replacement going wrong

1 reading
26K views 64 replies 17 participants last post by  Reserector  
#1 ·
Hi there fellow riders.
I purchased a 2012 FJR1300 with 7400 miles on it in late May, and at the time of purchase I had noticed that the right fork seal was l weeping oil a little. 2000 miles later and I'm trying to do my first fork seal replacement job and I've run into an issue.

I have the new seal loaded into the fork, and last night at 1am while I was trying to get it seated I noticed the fork tube bound up and won't move. I tried to get it to release for about an hour, including using a floor jack and some wood to try and push it loose to no avail.
Anyone got any tips on how to unbork this before I cause too much expensive damage?

Thanks in advance!
 

Attachments

#32 ·
If you follow the FSM....... you measure the oil level before you install the springs... i.e., you install the cartridge first without the spring, add oil, stroke the cartridge to get rid of air, recheck oil level, install spring, etc. You can't put in the same amount as the FSM says, most aftermarket spring manufacturers will tell you to put a much lower level of oil in...... FSM says 90mm for the right leg, but your new springs are more robust, need more air..... 120-130mm would be appropriate on both legs.
 
#33 ·
The thing I can't figure out is how to install the spring in the right leg after putting the oil in. The spring is captive in the cartridge and you have to hold a nut below the spring to tighten the nut/washer that holds the spring from the top. I guess I just need to go by the level in the fork and not go by the amount of oil I add.
 
#34 ·
You hold the cartridge rod when you are tightening the top nut. Sometimes there is a flat on the rods for a wrench, I just use a needle nose vice grip.
 
#35 · (Edited)
17mm wrench on the preload adjuster, that's what the 14mm nut is jammed against. Using the two wrenches, loosen the nut, unscrew the fork cap, remove rebound rod. Next remove nut and washer, next remove spring. Establish fork oil level. Cycle fork tube and cartridge rod to remove air, adjust fork oil level as necessary.
Assembly is the reverse, make sure nut is fully down so fork cap (preload aduster portion) is bottomed on the cartridge tube, run nut up and snug it. In other words, just follow the FSM.

Important note, if you have a 2016-up, there is an additional step to set the distance the fork cap screws on, otherwise rebound damping will not be adjustable. Reminder to all those who do not put their bike in their profile or signature line, please do it so we can better help you.
 
#37 ·
Additional note, On Gen3, if you remove the rebound rod and turn the cartridge upside down while draining the old oil out, be aware the spring and tapered needle may slide out, so check your drain pan. Just put it back in, spring first, then needle. When you push down on the rebound rod, you should feel the spring pushing back against you...... just an FYI..


Image
 
#38 ·
Yesterday while cleaning my '15 FJR1300A w 16K miles I found out that I joined the leaking fork seal club. I noticed a few drops of fork oil seating just on top of the left fork, the right is perfectly fine. Not a significant of fork oil yet but clearly the beginning of a leak. First thing I'd like to try is Seal doctor to see if that helps but i'm not going to hold my breath.

Reading this thread makes want to remove the fork the bike and take it to a shop to have them replace it instead of me attempting to replace the seal, but I've lost confidence on shops to do the job right. I've replaced the fork seals one time on a Voyager 1700 i had, but I do not remember it to be as intricate as the steps mentioned in this thread. The trick on the forks of the Kawasaki was to remove the allen bolt at the bottom of the fork before attempting to pull them apart.

I'm equipped with the service manual and i will be looking at the steps involved on how to accomplish this task. Aside from the fork seal do I really need to replaced the bushings mentioned above?. If I'm going to go thru all of the steps mentioned above I'm just going to order OEM parts.
 
#41 ·
Attention all Gen3A users..... since we've had a few incidents with broken compression valves on the bottom of the cartridges, and the fact you can't get cartridges for '13-'15's......I no longer recommend using an air impact gun to remove the bottom bolt. Manual method better. There are two ways to do this, but likely you'll end up with the second way.....

Just a note on the 16'-ups..... cartridges now have crimped in compression valves, no option but a new cartridge if broken, ie, no aftermarket compression valves will work.

As mentioned for your Voyager, you can start by trying to remove the bottom bolt while the forks are still assembled... wind the preload in all the way to maximize the pressure of the cartridge pushing against the bottom of the fork, which will help keep the cartridge from turning as you loosen the bolt. However, what may happen is, the cartridge will spin, thus you can't unthread the bolt.

So, method two, is to now disassemble the top cap and remove the springs and dump the oil (beware of rebound damping needle and spring falling out into your drain pan). Then use a cartridge holding tool on the brass nut at the top of the cartridge to keep it from spinning. In my pic, I made a prototype from 1" PVC to look like the OEM tool... it worked, but not all that well because it is plastic. Better yet, a simple cheap an EZ one, using 1" thin wall square tubing, a good length is ~16" (12" is a bit too short). Cut slits up the corners approx. 5/8", this leaves you 4 tabs, cut two opposite ones off. Then bend the two remaining out until the opening is ~30mm.

The brass nut on top of the cartridge is 26mm hex, so your 30mm tapered opening will go down and engage two flats of the hex nut. You can drill a hole in the upper end of the tubing for a bolt, or clamp on with some vice grips as a handle. If you did not break the lower bolt loose earlier, do it now (cartridge will spin), then engage the holding tool and finish removing the bolt. Then remove the cartridge.

Once all seals and bushings replaced, tubes back together, put the oil lock piece on the bottom of the cartridge and slide it into the fork. Get the lower bolt started and snug it up until seated. Then you shouldn't really need the cartridge holding tool to torque up the lower bolt...... use only enough torque to seal against the copper washer, do not overtorque. Yammy spec is 25 ft. lbs, remember it's a lubed fastener, so drop that to 18-20 max.


Bushings and Seals...... The only real way to get the seals out is to slide hammer the forks apart, which destroys the lower and middle bushings, and maybe the upper one is salvageable. Two things will help you. An absolute must is heat, on the upper part where the upper bushing and seal reside..... hot enough you can't touch it. First remove the bug deflector pieces....

When slide hammering, it might be beneficial to not be perfectly "in line", since the lower bushing might jam in the middle bushing and bind up. You may have to have a big rubber hammer handy to hammer the inner tube back in to release it..... and as you have likely read, some weren't able to do that and had to resort to other measures. Did they use heat, I don't know. BTW, don't forget to remove the wire seal retaining ring first, lol. DAMHIK.

IF you have access to a tall press, you can initially fill the fork with some kind of oil, reinstall the fork cap and hydraulically press the fork together.... it will amaze you with the ease at which the seal eases out under hydraulic pressure.... wish I had room for one.


Image
 
#42 ·
Ray sed--
IF you have access to a tall press, you can initially fill the fork with some kind of oil, reinstall the fork cap and hydraulically press the fork together.... it will amaze you with the ease at which the seal eases out under hydraulic pressure.... wish I had room for one.


Just have to show a little ingenuity.
Park the car with the tire in line with the edge of the garage door opening a little more than a fork leg length away (may have to make several tries to get the right spacing).
Put a plank on edge against the side of the tire.
Place the fork leg full of oil (any oil, it needed replacing anyway) horizontally on top of an oil drain pan between the edge of the door opening and the plank against the tire. Put a deep socket on top of the fork cap.
Place a scissors jack between the socket on top of the fork leg and the plank against the tire.
Spin the scissors jack with the impact gun until the oil seal pushes out of the lower leg. Oil pan catches the mess.
Pick up the parts, put the car back in the garage.

Avoids disassembling the fork leg and slide hammering the bushings if all that's needed is to replace the seal.


Bet the wheels are spinning now!!

dan



Ideas are like rabbits. You get a couple and learn how to handle them, and pretty soon you have a dozen. --John Steinbeck
 
#48 ·
Avoids disassembling the fork leg and slide hammering the bushings if all that's needed is to replace the seal.
Bet the wheels are spinning now!!
dan

Ideas are like rabbits. You get a couple and learn how to handle them, and pretty soon you have a dozen. --John Steinbeck
I need clarification on this. All is needed at this point is to potentially replace the seal. Don't I have to pull the inner tube and cylinder out to remove the seal and install the new one?

I wish there was a way to pull the oil seal from the top, of course after removing the dust seal and ring, instead of disassembling the fork.
 
#44 ·
Thanks, Dan, wheels are spinning now...... I'm thinkin' a vertical press I could make.... push up to the top of my garage door opening....
BTW, what do you mean put the car back in the garage? You let cars in yours? 😁 ;)

Just an FYI, if your forks have 30k or so on them, the lower bushing has wear, teflon thinning and copper showing..... however, I've had others at 50k with little wear... non-aggressive rider. But once you have the seal out, slide hammering the upper bushing out should be a lot easier..... I'd still use heat as it is a significant interference fit (more than any other bike's forks I've worked on).
 
#45 ·
Thanks, Dan, wheels are spinning now...... I'm thinkin' a vertical press I could make.... push up to the top of my garage door opening....
I didn't think of parking the car in the garage door opening, put the scissors jack on the hood and push up against the top of the door opening. :unsure:

BTW, what do you mean put the car back in the garage? You let cars in yours?
In my neck of the woods, hail storms are not uncommon any time of the year. IMHO it makes more sense to keep the cars in the garage rather than leaving them outside while protecting $25 worth crap inside. The scooter parks between them. If it saves having to deal with insurance claims and body shops, it's worth the squeeze. I do have to set them outside temporarily sometimes to have room to work on other things.

dan


The road goes on forever, and the party never ends. -- Robert Earl Keen
 
  • Like
Reactions: RaYzerman
#47 ·
I wasn't going to use the car..... hydraulic floor jack on the floor, fork on top of it, suitable support post up to the top of the opening... how to keep it all straight, thus the word 'suitable'. Wheels are still spinnin'
 
#52 ·
I have seen a few forks butchered up by guys trying to remove the seal with various things like Oldjeep is saying. He's absolutely right, you should have experience as a wrench turner before trying it.
The dan cooper method is great.... hey, maybe you got a buddy who has a friend who has one of those presses... I do but he's in VA.

A fork oil leak bad enough to run down the fork leg will get into your brake pads...... wrap a rag around it and zip tie it, see how much leakage you're getting after a ride.......

If you have the room and need more tools........... this will work. OR, copy the concept, which is what dan is saying.

 
  • Like
Reactions: robbyk
#53 ·
So........ prototype...... what if I bolt a length of angle iron on the wall, at the height of a fork, put say a 6' 2x4 on edge under it, suitable something so the fork cap doesn't get damaged, keep the fork within a foot of the wall...... a six foot piece as a pry lever should give me lots of mechanical advantage, yes? If that works, spin the wheels some more.
 
#54 ·
I was just thinking about a giant version of a bead breaker!! I think I would anchor the bottom of the fork leg at the floor / wall junction so nothing could jump, with the top end about a foot or maybe less out. A triangle is a very strong geometric form. It doesn't take much travel to push the seal out if the fork is completely full of oil. Actually, the fork leg wouldn't have to be filled with oil, it could be any other liquid. Even water, which would be less of a mess to clean up. :unsure:


dan (spinning his wheels)
 
  • Like
Reactions: RaYzerman
#56 · (Edited)
Well, I too encountered this problem with a jammed inner tube in the outer tube. The right fork started leaking on my wife's 2014 FJR1300A, and I decided I would rebuild both forks while I was at it. I started with the left one first, and was able to slide-hammer the oil seal and top bushing with little problem...just took my time and went slow and didn't apply too much force with each slide. It did bind up several times (while pulling the tube out), although I was able to gently smack the bottom of the outer tube on a thick folded rag on the garage floor while holding the inner tube to get it unstuck.

When I got to the right fork, it ended up binding up and I wasn't able to get it unstuck. I tried to get it unbound by the same process that I used on the left fork, but to no avail...I wound up with the inner tube almost bottomed out in the outer tube.

Thanks to your posts on here detailing the success of pulling the inner tube from the outer tube, I devised a clamp to hold the inner tube, and then rigged it up on my cherry picker...and success! Next time, I'll take the time to push the oil seal using the hydraulic pressure method (filling the fork with oil), as I have a press...I figured I could skip this part and just use the slide-hammer method. I do think extracting the oil seal before slide-hammering the bushings will make a difference and just might be able to extract the bushings with a little less force.

I used 1.5" aluminum angle, coupled with U-bolts. I notched the peaks of the aluminum angle where the U-bolts contacted. I also pre-bent the backing piece to a similar shape, and once I tightened the nuts, the backing further formed to the right-angle shape of the aluminum. I also pulled on just one side of the aluminum, as it naturally created a compression clamp on the fork as the pulling force was applied. I also reinstalled the top cap in the fork as some measure of assurance the top of the inner tube would not deform from the force.

Image


Image



The below is a pic after the inner tube was separated from the outer tube...one side of the angle slid a little bit, which just helped to further compress the clamping force on the inner fork. No marring occurred on the inner tube.

Image
 
#57 ·
I recently pulled my Gen1 forks apart to replace the seals and bushings. I first placed the lower leg in the soft jaws of my vice and promptly noticed the upper tube got real tight - I was crushing the tube - a BAD thing. I then gripped the lower tube in the vise on the bottom end where the axle goes thru and luckily the tube returned to shape. After applying a bit of heat from a Bernzo-matic torch on the lower tube, the upper tube along with the bushing and seal popped out quite easy. I now need to find some 2" exhaust tubing to pres the new ones back in. FWIW, my Gen1 cartridge does not have a hex on the top so a socket tool will not work. I used the friction/impact wrench method to remove the cartridge attachment bolts.
 
#58 ·
Best place to hold the lowers in the vice is by both caliper mounting pads. Assuming you have a vice that you can rotate so that the jaws are vertical.
 
#59 ·
To install the upper bushing, I use the big washer and a piece of 2" ABS or PVC pipe. This also is my seal driver.
Yes, I hold the lower fork by the caliper mounts in the vice.

On Gen1, there is a pressed on washer on the nut on top of the cartridge. What others have done is make a wire hook to get it off, then you can use a tool to hold the cartridge (psst, I've never done it, and used an air impact on the lower bolt).
If not successful getting the bolt out, but loose..... one thing we've had to do (since the Gen1 fork springs are so weak), is to max the preload, then compress the fork (piece of plywood against the fork cap while compressing against your chest). Requires a helper.
 
#60 · (Edited)
On Gen1, there is a pressed on washer on the nut on top of the cartridge. What others have done is make a wire hook to get it off...
-> Maybe - I tried it. It is pressed on really hard. I removed them by tapping them with a hammer after I got the forks disassembled. You may be able to remove them using a piece of 1/8" tig rod with a hook on the end and try to pop them off. Yamaha should have just made the washers loose to set them on top of the hex nut. I plan to open up the washer hole a bit with a file so it can be removed easily next time.
 
#62 ·
Oil seal, washer,snap ring. And then the dust seal.